Migraine Medication Selector
Find Your Best Migraine Treatment Alternative
Answer these questions to discover which medications might work best for you
Your Health Profile
If you’ve been prescribed Maxalt (rizatriptan) for migraines, you’re not alone. Millions use it to stop attacks fast. But what if it doesn’t work for you? Or maybe it gives you side effects like dizziness, fatigue, or a weird chest tightness? You’re not broken-you just might need a different tool. There are other triptans, non-triptan options, and even over-the-counter combos that could work better. Let’s cut through the noise and compare Maxalt with real alternatives that actually help people.
What Maxalt (Rizatriptan) Actually Does
Maxalt is a rizatriptan is a selective serotonin receptor agonist used to treat acute migraine attacks with or without aura. It was approved by the FDA in 1998 and quickly became a go-to because of how fast it works. It doesn’t prevent migraines. It stops them in progress.
When a migraine hits, blood vessels in your brain swell and nerves get irritated. Rizatriptan tightens those vessels and calms the pain signals. Most people feel relief within 30 to 60 minutes. By two hours, about 70% of users report their headache is gone or much better.
But here’s the catch: it doesn’t work for everyone. About 1 in 4 people don’t get enough relief. Others get side effects that make them avoid it altogether. That’s where alternatives come in.
Other Triptans: The Closest Alternatives
Maxalt isn’t the only triptan. There are seven FDA-approved ones. They all work the same way-but their speed, duration, and side effects vary.
Here’s how Maxalt stacks up against the most common ones:
| Medication | Generic Name | Onset of Relief | Duration | Common Side Effects |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Maxalt | Rizatriptan | 30-60 minutes | 2-4 hours | Dizziness, fatigue, nausea |
| Sumatriptan | Sumatriptan | 30-60 minutes | 2-4 hours | Chest tightness, tingling, flushing |
| Zolmitriptan | Zolmitriptan | 45-90 minutes | 4-6 hours | Drowsiness, dry mouth, dizziness |
| Eletriptan | Eletriptan | 45-90 minutes | 6-8 hours | Nausea, fatigue, muscle weakness |
| Almotriptan | Almotriptan | 60-90 minutes | 4-6 hours | Nausea, dizziness, dry mouth |
Some people find that switching from Maxalt to zolmitriptan is a triptan available as a tablet or nasal spray, often used when rizatriptan causes dizziness helps because it lasts longer. Others swear by eletriptan is a triptan with higher success rates in severe migraines, though it has more drug interactions because it’s more effective for intense pain-even if it takes longer to kick in.
Sumatriptan is the oldest and cheapest, but chest tightness scares a lot of people. It’s not a heart attack, but it feels like one. If you have heart risk factors, your doctor will avoid it.
Non-Triptan Options: When Triptans Don’t Cut It
Not everyone can take triptans. If you have high blood pressure, heart disease, or just can’t tolerate the side effects, you need something else.
Here are the three most common non-triptan alternatives:
1. Ubrelvy (Ubrogepant)
Ubrogepant is part of a new class called gepants are a class of migraine medications that block CGRP receptors, a key player in migraine pain pathways. Unlike triptans, they don’t narrow blood vessels. That makes them safer for people with heart issues.
Studies show Ubrelvy works in about 60% of users within two hours. Side effects are mild: nausea, drowsiness, dry mouth. No chest tightness. It’s pricier than triptans, but if you’ve tried everything else, it’s worth a shot.
2. Nurtec ODT (Rimegepant)
Rimegepant is another gepant-but it’s also approved for preventing migraines. That’s rare. You can take it as needed for attacks, or once every other day to reduce frequency.
It works about as well as Maxalt, but with fewer side effects. The dissolving tablet is easy to use if you’re nauseous. Many people switch to Nurtec after Maxalt stopped working or made them feel worse.
3. Reyvow (Lasmiditan)
Lasmiditan is a ditan is a newer migraine medication that targets serotonin receptors without affecting blood vessels, reducing cardiovascular risk. It’s the newest option, approved in 2019.
It works fast-sometimes in 30 minutes. But it causes drowsiness in over half of users. You can’t drive or operate machinery for 8 hours after taking it. If you’re someone who needs to be alert after a migraine, this isn’t ideal. But if you can just lie down and wait it out, it’s powerful.
Over-the-Counter Options: Can They Help?
Some people try OTC painkillers first. But for true migraines, they often fall short.
Excedrin Migraine (acetaminophen + aspirin + caffeine) works for mild cases. A 2023 study in the Journal of Headache and Pain found it helped 58% of users with moderate migraines-but only 22% with severe ones.
NSAIDs like ibuprofen or naproxen can help if taken early. But they’re not reliable for frequent or severe attacks. Plus, long-term use can cause stomach issues or kidney stress.
Don’t expect OTC meds to replace Maxalt if your migraines are disabling. They’re better for prevention or as backup.
What Factors Should You Consider When Switching?
Choosing a replacement isn’t just about which drug works fastest. Here’s what actually matters:
- Speed vs. Duration: Do you need quick relief (Maxalt, rizatriptan) or longer-lasting control (eletriptan, rimegepant)?
- Safety: Do you have heart disease, high blood pressure, or stroke risk? Avoid triptans. Go for gepants or ditans.
- Side Effects: If Maxalt made you dizzy, try zolmitriptan or ubrogepant-they’re gentler on the head.
- Cost: Generic sumatriptan is cheap. Newer drugs like Nurtec cost $700+ per dose without insurance.
- Form: Can you swallow pills? Try nasal sprays (zolmitriptan) or dissolving tablets (Nurtec).
Many people don’t realize they can combine treatments. For example: take ibuprofen with Maxalt to reduce inflammation and boost pain relief. Always check with your doctor first.
When to Talk to Your Doctor
You shouldn’t switch meds on your own. But you should speak up if:
- Maxalt doesn’t work more than 3 times a month
- You need more than 10 doses a month
- You get side effects like chest pain, vision changes, or numbness
- Your migraines are getting worse or more frequent
Your doctor might suggest a preventive medication-like topiramate, propranolol, or even CGRP monoclonal antibodies (Emgality, Aimovig)-if you’re having migraines 8+ days a month.
Also, keep a headache diary. Note what you took, when it worked, how long it lasted, and what side effects you had. That’s the best way to find your perfect match.
Final Thoughts: There’s No One-Size-Fits-All
Maxalt is a great tool. Fast, reliable, widely available. But it’s not the only one. Some people find zolmitriptan easier on their stomach. Others feel like Nurtec gives them back their life. A few swear by Ubrelvy because it doesn’t make them feel "drugged."
The key is not to give up after one try. Migraine treatment is personal. It’s trial, error, and patience. What works for your coworker might do nothing for you. And that’s okay.
Don’t settle for pain. Talk to your doctor. Try one alternative. Track it. Then try another. There’s a solution out there. You just haven’t found it yet.
Is Maxalt better than sumatriptan?
Maxalt and sumatriptan work similarly, but Maxalt tends to work a bit faster and has fewer reports of chest tightness. Sumatriptan is cheaper and available as a nasal spray or injection, which helps if you’re vomiting. Neither is universally "better"-it depends on your body and what side effects you can tolerate.
Can I take Maxalt and ibuprofen together?
Yes, many people combine Maxalt with ibuprofen or naproxen. The painkiller helps with inflammation, while Maxalt targets the nerve signals. This combo can be more effective than either alone. Just don’t exceed the daily dose of ibuprofen (usually 1200 mg), and avoid it if you have stomach ulcers or kidney issues.
Are gepants safer than triptans?
Yes, gepants like Ubrelvy and Nurtec are safer for people with heart disease, high blood pressure, or a history of stroke. Triptans narrow blood vessels, which can be risky. Gepants don’t affect circulation, making them a top choice for those with cardiovascular concerns.
Why does Maxalt make me tired?
Fatigue is a common side effect of rizatriptan. It happens because the drug affects serotonin receptors in the brain, which can also regulate energy levels. If tiredness is a problem, switching to zolmitriptan or a gepant like Ubrelvy may help-they’re less sedating for most people.
How do I know if I need a preventive medication?
If you have migraines 8 or more days a month, or if your acute meds (like Maxalt) aren’t working well enough, it’s time to talk about prevention. Preventive options include daily pills (topiramate, propranolol) or monthly injections (CGRP blockers like Aimovig). These reduce frequency and severity over time.
Next Steps
Start by tracking your migraines for two weeks. Write down: when they hit, how bad they are (1-10), what you took, and how you felt afterward. Bring that to your doctor. Ask: "What’s the next best option if Maxalt isn’t working?" Then try one alternative at a time. Don’t rush. Your brain deserves the right fit-not just the first one you tried.
